Sept. 15, 2025

Ep 27 - Magazine Moments & Judgy Pants: When "Pro Organizer Tips" Meet Real Life

Originally aired on The JJ's Declutter Podcast - Episode 27

You know that feeling when you read a home organization article and immediately feel like you're failing at life? We've all been there. Those picture-perfect "6 Things Pro Organizers Always Throw Away" articles that make decluttering sound so simple—yet somehow leave you feeling more overwhelmed than inspired.

Well, grab your favorite beverage (Julie's got her sweet tea vodka ready) because we're putting on our "judgy pants" and diving into one of those very articles from The Spruce. Spoiler alert: we actually agreed with most of it, which means we had to wash our judgy pants afterward.

What Are "Magazine Moments" Anyway?

Magazine moments are those glossy, oversimplified decluttering tips that look perfect on paper but don't always translate to real homes with real families. Think of them as the Instagram filter of home organization—they make everything look effortless, but the reality is usually messier (literally and figuratively).

Julie and Janis coined this term for their monthly deep-dives into popular organizing articles, where they separate the genuinely helpful advice from the "easier said than done" suggestions that sound great but ignore how real people actually live.

The Spruce Article Breakdown: 6 Things to Toss Before Summer

The article in question recommended clearing out six categories of items before summer kicks in. Here's what made the list—and what Julie and Janis actually thought about each suggestion:

1. Winter Clothing and Accessories

The Article Says: Sort through old winter clothing, donate unworn sweaters, and toss stray gloves missing their matches.

Reality Check: This one passed the real-life test with flying colors. As you're washing and storing winter gear, it's the perfect time to evaluate what you'll actually want to pull out next winter. Julie's had some winter pieces for 15 years—but they're pieces she wears constantly during cold months. The key question: "Is this something I will want to pull out next winter or not?"

Pro tip from the JJs: If you haven't worn it all winter, you probably won't miss it. And those lonely gloves? Unless you're planning to become a one-handed person, it's time to let them go.

2. Expired Frozen and Pantry Goods

The Article Says: Clean out your freezer and pantry, toss expired items, and make room for summer staples.

Reality Check: Absolutely agree—with a side of humor. Julie admits to having chili that only comes out in cold months (and gets judgy about putting chili on hot dogs, much to Janis's amusement). The freezer cleanout is especially important because, as Janis points out, you need room for "freezer popsicles and ice cream."

Surprising fact: Julie shared that when she worked at a grocery store, they sold more ice cream in freezing weather than in summer. People would literally ski to the store for ice cream!

Summer pantry additions: Think Italian dressing for pasta salads, extra condiments for potato salad, and all the fixings for outdoor cooking. Don't forget to check those expiration dates—expired condiments won't make your summer BBQ memorable in a good way.

3. Old Summer Accessories

The Article Says: Go through beach bags, summer gear, and accessories before the season starts.

Reality Check: Smart timing. This includes checking sunscreen expiration dates (crucial for skin safety), evaluating flip-flops for wear, and deciding which sun hats are worth keeping. Julie organizes all summer gear into one tote at the end of each season, making it easy to reassess when she pulls it out the following year.

The "when in doubt, don't throw out" rule: If you're on the fence about keeping something as you pack it away, keep it. Make the decision when you unpack it next season—you'll have a clearer perspective then.

4. Old Linens and Towels

The Article Says: Evaluate your beach towel collection and go through your linen closet.

Reality Check: This sparked an entertaining discussion about towel preferences. Julie loves bath sheets (those giant towels), but her husband Phil hates them—so much so that he'll grab them for garage projects just to get them out of the bathroom rotation.

Donation tip: Don't just toss old linens. Donate them to thrift stores or animal shelters where they can get a second life.

Reality note: Not everyone has a linen closet. Julie keeps sheets under beds and towels in the bathroom. Adapt the advice to your actual storage situation.

5. Old Outdoor Toys

The Article Says: If kids have outgrown outdoor toys, donate them now to make space for age-appropriate equipment.

Reality Check: The JJs loved the line "kids grow fast, but clutter grows faster." This resonated especially with Julie, who's been transitioning her fairy garden decorations as her grandchildren outgrow them. Some of her Dollar Tree garden finds have been going strong for 10+ years (back when the Dollar Tree actually cost a dollar).

Key insight: You don't need to replace everything you remove. Kids are remarkably adaptable and often won't even notice missing toys—especially if they have access to a sprinkler to run through.

6. School Papers

The Article Says: Sort through the year's collection of artwork and papers, keeping only the best.

Reality Check: This one hit close to home for Julie, who shared a story about wanting specific pieces back from a teacher but waiting too long to ask. Her advice: Ask your kids to choose their favorites, and check with them about anything special they want to bring home before the school year ends.

Creative disposal tip: If you compost, shred old school papers and let the kids add them to the compost bin. They'll love seeing their schoolwork help grow things in the garden (just be prepared for them to want to shred everything afterward).

The Verdict: Surprisingly Sensible

Unlike some organizing articles that feel completely disconnected from reality, this one earned the JJ seal of approval. The suggestions were practical, well-timed, and achievable for most households.

The key difference? These weren't perfectionistic "transform your entire home in one weekend" mandates. They were seasonal, logical transitions that work with natural rhythms—like cleaning out winter gear as you put it away, or going through school papers at the end of the academic year.

Making "Magazine Moments" Work for Real Life

Here's how to adapt professional organizer advice to your actual life:

Start with what makes sense for YOUR household. Not everyone needs to declutter beach towels if they live far from water, and not every family has the same seasonal rhythms.

Use the "would I buy this today?" test. If you wouldn't purchase that worn-out item right now, it's probably time to let it go.

Involve your family in decisions. Kids often have different attachments to items than adults do—let them have input on what stays.

Think seasonally, not overwhelmingly. These six categories spread across late spring/early summer are much more manageable than trying to declutter your entire house at once.

Remember that "good enough" is actually good enough. You don't need to achieve magazine-perfect organization to benefit from these seasonal cleanouts.

The Real Magic: Judgment-Free Decluttering

What made this article work was its practical timing and realistic scope. Instead of demanding perfection, it suggested manageable seasonal maintenance that most people can actually accomplish.

The JJs' "judgy pants" approach isn't about being mean—it's about applying real-world perspective to organizing advice. Sometimes that means calling out unrealistic expectations, and sometimes (like this episode) it means giving credit where credit is due.

Your Summer Decluttering Action Plan

Ready to tackle your own pre-summer cleanup? Here's your realistic, judgment-free checklist:

This week: Pick ONE category from the list that resonates with your current situation.

Set a timer: Give yourself 15-30 minutes max. This isn't about perfection—it's about progress.

Use the "one in, two out" rule: If you're buying new summer items, consider letting go of old ones to make space.

Remember Julie's wisdom: "When in doubt, don't throw it out"—until next season when you'll have better perspective.

Celebrate small wins: Cleared out three expired condiments? That's a victory worth acknowledging.

The goal isn't to achieve some impossible standard of organization. It's to make your space work better for your family's summer plans, whether that involves camping gear, beach towels, or just having room in the freezer for ice cream (which, according to Julie's grocery store experience, you'll want regardless of the weather).

So put on your own judgy pants if you need to, evaluate what actually makes sense for your home, and remember: the best organizing system is the one you'll actually use.

Want to hear Julie and Janis's full take on this article, complete with stories about Phil's sauerkraut obsession and childhood complaints about too much steak? Listen to Episode 27 of The JJ's Declutter Podcast, where real-life decluttering meets honest conversation.

Connect with The JJ's: